TABLE 3.

The 40 Statements and the Factor Array Scores of the 4 Factors

No StatementFactors
F1F2F3+F3−F4
Context (Use Case)
1Microscopy using a concentration technique is the recommended method to prove active schistosomiasis, despite its low sensitivity and need for expert users. 0−1−1−2−3
2Diagnosis should include the identification of Schistosoma parasites in both humans and water sources that may be contaminated.+20+4+20
3Mass screening and diagnosis should be carried out alongside mass drug administration with praziquantel. −2−3+4−25
4Schistosomiasis surveillance enables program managers to monitor the effectiveness of intervention strategies and identify which populations require continuing interventions. −1+5+2−1+3
5The availability of RDTs, which requires only minimal infrastructure, would improve diagnosis and surveillance simultaneously.+3−2b+3+2+5
6Implementing an affordable and simple POC diagnostics solution will reduce the financial burden of equipment and personnel at each health facility. 0b−2−24b−1
7POC diagnostics that can detect and confirm cases immediately will reduce the risk of missed or misdiagnosed cases. +20−3a01
8The quantification of egg excretion helps to assess the transmission potential of populations living in endemic areas. −1−21−1−2
9Schistosomiasis control programs should target school-aged children only.−6−6−1b−5−6
10Due to the low level of education and lack of training among community health workers, incorrect treatment is often prescribed.−3a−1003b
11Presenting data on the severity of schistosomiasis infection of specific locations will guide the development of strategies for effective case management and control elimination. +1+2−6b+3+1
12Passive case detection, based on people’s self-reporting, has been considered a less expensive strategy for the control of schistosomiasis.−3−26b00
13Prevalence and intensity of infection is often higher among children than among adults. 0−1−3+10
Infrastructure and location
14Schistosomiasis diagnosis should be done closest to the community as it reduces the time to carry samples back to the laboratory.0+120+4
15Diagnostic and treatment campaigns should target school-age children, adolescents and those whose occupations involve contact with infectious water (e.g. fishing, farming, irrigation, and domestic tasks in water).−2+3+1+1−1
16Simple, rapid POC tests should be used in primary health care settings where patients often travel long distances to access health care facilities.−1−1−2+2+2
17Diagnostic devices should be deployed in primary health care centers, clinics, and health posts since they are the most lacking in equipment.−4a+4−1a+51a
18Testing of urine samples for schistosomiasis with school-based surveys should be done at the school location.−1+10−2−5
19It is convenient to treat patients for schistosomiasis infection without a confirmed diagnosis due to the delay in receiving test results from referral hospitals. −5−5−5−4−4
Product requirement
20Schistosomiasis elimination calls for developing novel diagnostic tools with higher sensitivity and specificity than microscopes.+13b−4−1−3
21Diagnostic device for schistosomiasis with minimal to no sample preparation is ideal. −2−3−2−3−5a
22The diagnostic device should quantify eggs to provide an estimation of the number of people that have been exposed to schistosomiasis in a population. 5a−5b+1−1a+2
23Devices should be easy to use by medical personnel and health workers such as CHEWs, CHOs, laboratory scientists to detect and diagnose schistosomiasis-infected patients.+1+20−5−2
24Patient samples should be processed in batches to get a faster turnaround time and increase the efficiency of sample processing during mass campaigns or sensitization meetings. 00+1−4b+3
25Ideal diagnostic approaches should allow the concurrent detection of several pathogens in different biological samples such as urine, blood, and stool.+30+3−3a+1
26Diagnostic devices should be sensitive enough for detecting very light schistosomiasis infections. +4−3+5−1−1
27Diagnostic devices should have their own reliable power sources due to the unstable power connectivity in rural and distant communities. +6−1−1+6+6
28The best diagnostic devices should be easy to transport safely by car, motorbike, and bicycle to remote locations.4a+1−4+2−1
29Diagnostic devices should be compact and portable so that they can be easily deployed in the community. +20a+3+3−3b
30Diagnostic devices/tests should identify and map out areas with a large spread of schistosomiasis and be able to trace the source of the disease. 3a000−1
31Devices should be locally repaired and maintained by local technicians in case of breakdown.0+2−5b+40
32The device should be easy to clean and disinfect to prevent re-contamination. +1+10+1+2
Rollout strategy
33The cost per diagnostic test should be free (covered by the government).−14a0+1−2
34Cost per diagnostic test should be less than 1,000 Naira (US$2).−5b6a−3+3a−2
35Mass drug administration campaigns should be accompanied by mass diagnostic and disease awareness campaigns. −2+2+210
36Data from diagnostic devices should be accessible to stakeholders (local government, DSNO, MOH, researchers, and NGOs) to enhance planning.+1+5+20+2
37New interventions should consider training the health care workers at the community level and the informal sector (PMVs and traditional medicine) to increase coverage to diagnostics.−3+1−1−6b0
38Diagnostic tools for schistosomiasis should be deployed and used at the community level by PMVs and community mobilizers as they already serve as trusted stakeholders in the community.−4−41b−3−4
39The role of the village/community head is important in the acceptance of the new diagnostic device.+5−4a−2a+51b
40Patients with schistosomiasis should be tested before being treated.+2+3+5−2b+4
  • Abbreviations: CHEW, community health extension worker; CHO, community health officer; DSNO, disease surveillance notification officer; MOH, medical officer of health; NGO, nongovernmental organization; PMV, patent medicine vendor; POC, point-of-care; RDT, rapid diagnostic test.

  • a Distinguishing statement significant at P<.05.

  • b Distinguishing statement significant at P<.01.